According to diotima, love is not a god at all, but is rather a spirit that mediates between people and the objects of their desire. It is a discussion on the nature of love, taking the form of a group of speeches, both satirical. Paradoxes in platos symposium volume 14 issue 2 steven lowenstam. This conversation occurred at an unspecified time previous to the dinner and may actually be a fictitious conversationdiotima is generally regarded a fictional creation of socrates within the dialogues. At one point in the book, the reader gets an impression about the speakers favoring homosexuality as some of them argue about the purity of love more in the. The guests decide not to get drunk, but drinking a. Saunders, plato on women in the laws edited by anton powell, london and new york. Eros and the three sexes in platos symposium michael groneberg even the lover of myth philomythos is in a sense a lover of wisdom philosophos, for myth is composed of wonders.
The sequence of dazzling speeches culminates in socrates famous account of the views of diotima, a prophetess who taught him that love is our. The guestsincluding the comic poet aristophanes and plato s mentor socrateseach deliver a short speech in praise of love. A macat analysis of plato s the symposium translated by m. In the dialogue, her ideas are the origin of the concept of platonic love.
The symposium quotes by plato goodreads share book. It depicts a friendly contest of extemporaneous speeches given by a group of notable men attending a banquet. This study guide consists of approximately 29 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of symposium. Giving specific attention to diotima speech is imperative to understanding to the role of ideas in real life. Socrates then relates a story he was told by a wise woman called diotima. In the end, they summarized the ideas based on the teachings of a priestess, diotima. Why is pregnancy so central to diotima s account of love. Symposium by plato diotima questions socrates and the. On one level the book deals with the genealogy, nature and purpose of love, on another level the book deals with the topic of knowledge, specifically how does one know what one knows. In plato s symposium drinking together, he introduced the teachings of a woman whom socrates claimed was wise about eros and many other things. Diotima s speech describes eros at its last stage before reaching the finality of eternal contemplation, as the place. Chapter five examines the links between eros and vulnerability.
Agathon, pausanias, and diotima in plato s symposium. Diotima of mantinea was an ancient greek prophetess and philosopher thought to have lived circa 440 b. Scientific, religious, and philosophical conceptions of womans nature indiana, 1993. Sep 07, 2016 the dramatic nature of plato s dialogues is delightfully evident in symposium. Instead, plato introduces diotima as a prophetic figure who does know the truth about love and who can lead socrates toward it. The national endowment for the humanities provided support for entering this text. Symposium is central in platos philosophy, since it talks about love and ideas. His teacher, socrates, chose not to write anything down in books or treatises re. In the final section, where plato s revered teacher, socrates, recalls how he went to the seer diotima of mantinea and she told him that love was a ladder, on which one progressed from physical. Pomeroy, feminism in book v of plato s republic, apeiron 8 1974 3235. Symposium the ladder of love by allan bloom on plato s symposium by seth benardete includes bibliographical references counter plato, allan bloom wrote, is the most erotic of philosophers, and his symposium is one of the greatest works on the nature of love ever written. The dramatic nature of plato s dialogues is delightfully evident in symposium. The work itself is believed to have been composed sometime between 385 bc and 370 bc. Platos symposium plato philosophy learn with flashcards, games, and more for free.
Plato s symposium and the traditions of ancient fiction, richard hunter 14. Plato s styles and characters, between literature and philosophy, university of brasilia, august 222012. Symposium by plato diotima questions socrates and the speech. A model of the kind of text one needs for lecture courses. Socrates and diotima from platos symposium youtube. Plato s famous piece of literature, the symposium, is striking with its speeches of love, or eros, which translates to desire. You said, i think, that the troubles among the gods were composed by love of beauty, for there. Aristophanes account of love in platos symposium essay. Platos symposium by plato on free audio book download. Plato s symposium contains several fascinating histories of the nature of love. Discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers new books every 1, 2, or 3 months new customers receive 15% off your. This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the symposium plato article.
Cambridge university press, 2008 it may sound like the setup for a joke a playwright, a philosopher, and a general walk into party. A symposium is a semiformal banquet consisting of only men, followed by ceremonial toasts and. The unexpected arrival of alcibiades breaks the spell cast by diotimas ethereal climb up the staircase of love to beauty itself. Free kindle book and epub digitized and proofread by project gutenberg. Together, this book has been designed in such a way that, once readers have mastered the core list, they will be able to rely solely on the greek. The symposium is one of plato s most beloved and widely read dialogues. Socrates himself never wrote a line that we know of.
Against those who read the symposium s ladder of love as a move away from loving the ordinary and imperfect, i advocate an understanding of philosophy that retains a care for the imperfect and ordinary. Alcibiades and his speech play a crucial role in the symposium, because they serve as a platonic image complementing socrates speech. Diotima was an ancient greek prophetess and philosopher thought to have lived circa 440 b. Paper given at the first latin american area conference of the international plato society and x archai international seminar. The marriage between character and thought bursts forth as the guests gather at agathons house to celebrate the success of his first tragedy. Purchase a copy of this text not necessarily the same edition from.
According to socrates in the republic, images serve as a first step on the path to understanding imagination is the first part of the divided line the republic, 511 d, and thus are the most accessible form in which somebody can be put on the path to knowledge. Symposium establishes philosophy and the life of the philosopher as critical to the good life. At the start of the dialogue the party agreed that each man no women present would make the finest speech he could in praise of eros. Unlike others in the symposium, diotima introduces eross parents as poros resource and penia poverty, at the plotting of penia while poros was drunk on nectar they become impregnated with eros. Socrates and aristodemus will attend a banquet at agathon, with aristophanes, appolodore, pausanias and eryximachus. Platos symposium and diotimas ladder of love platos dialogue the symposium is one of the key texts of the platonic tradition. Both of these instances in platos dialogue have been used to argue for her existence. A discussion on the theme of love took place at this symposium, a discussion which has since become famous. So dialogue plays a smaller role in the symposium than it does in plato s other dialogues. The greek word sumposion means a drinking party a fact shamefully ignored by the organizers of modern symposia, and the party described in plato s symposium is one supposedly given in the year 416 bc by the playwright agathon to celebrate his victory i. A reading of plato s symposium, diotima s speech translated by eleanor h. A reading of platos symposium, diotimas speech luce irigaray translated by eleanor h. Full text of the symposium of plato, internet archive. The guests decide not to get drunk, but drinking a little and discuss about love.
The hangover of plato s symposium in the italian renaissance from bruni 1435 to castiglione 1528, diskin clay 16. Plato symposium 206c212c diotima s speech 1 duration. Paradoxes in platos symposium ramus cambridge core. Philosophers have been grappling with the question since plato put it. Socrates is renowned for his dialectic approach to knowledge often referred to as the socratic. What statements could be given for believing that this is the right construct of love. This critical guide to plato s symposium fits the mold admirably. This is the discourse between socrates and diotima from plato s symposium.
Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Kevin corrigan, and elena glazovcorrigan its literary sensibility and systematic lucidity make this work a remarkable contribution to the debates concerning plato s symposium as well as the vexata quaestio of the relation between poetry and philosophy or, more broadly, art, literature, imagination, and thinking. Plato, of course, is the author of so many dialogs that are, individually and collectively, intricate and mind blowing works. And now, taking my leave of you, i would rehearse a tale of love which i heard from diotima of mantineia, a woman wise in this and in many other kinds of knowledge, who in the days of old, when the athenians offered sacrifice before the coming of the plague, delayed the disease ten years. Plato, we do well to remember, is not bound to say all he knows in every dialogue. Love is neither wise nor beautiful, but is rather the desire for wisdom and beauty.
The greek word sumposion means a drinking party a fact shamefully ignored by the organizers of modern symposia, and the party described in plato s symposium is one supposedly given in the year 416 bc by the playwright agathon to celebrate his victory in the dramatic festival of the lenaea. He has already given one party, the previous evening. My first foray into plato and a good place to start an easy going quick read book. Diotima is introduced to perpetuate the dialogue and to speak from a position of authority about love. Symposium is central in plato s philosophy, since it talks about love and ideas. In platos symposium, the priestess diotima, whom socrates introduces as an. In the symposium, diotima puts forth ideas that are different from both socratess and platos, thereby representing a different philosophical position. The text has been credited with influencing how western literature portrays and interprets love and beauty. And the introduction admirably presents both basic. Diotima s ascent to beauty symposium 201212 i n plato s philosophy, god is termed the good, or the form of the good. Its theme is eroserotic love, the allconsuming passion that has inspired countless poems, plays, novels, songs, operas and in our day movies. The significance of alcibiades and his speech in platos.
Inside each philosophy guide youll find insightful overviews of great philosophical works of the western world. The symposium is a philosophical text by plato dated c. For my money a good translation, very readable and entertaining and good forward explaining the work, which i read afterwards. Socrates speech and diotima and now, taking my leave of you, i would rehearse a tale of love which i heard from diotima of mantineia, a woman wise in this and in many other kinds of knowledge, who in the days of old, when the athenians offered sacrifice before the coming of the plague, delayed the disease ten years. Aristodemus, who was present, reported the conversation to phoinix and apollodorus. Paul allen miller argues that the debates that emerged from the burgeoning of feminist intellectual life in postmodern france involved complex, structured, and reciprocal exchanges on the interpretation and position. The question and answer section for symposium by plato is a great resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss the novel.
Quoting diotima questioning socrates, plato adds another layer of distance from the reader. Nancy tuana is professor of philosophy at the university of oregon and author of several books, including most recently the less noble sex. Sparknotes philosophy guides are onestop guides to the great works of philosophymasterpieces that stand at the foundations of western thought. The surprising influence of the symposium on legal theory, jeffrey carnes part iv. The love ladder is more complex and nuanced than this, and theres a great deal of psychology at work here. Symposium by plato diotima questions socrates and the speech of diotima summary and analysis. Sep 07, 2016 this is the discourse between socrates and diotima from plato s symposium. Explain at least three ways in which plato demonstrates that he has drawn upon the ideas of. Kuykendall sorcerer love is the name that luce irigaray gives to the demonic function of. Buy the symposium penguin classics rev ed by plato, christopher gill isbn. Plato wrote the symposium about the ancient athenian cultural tradition in which men would drink, discuss philosophical subjects, compose speeches and sing songs.
If you want to know what the beautiful itself is, join the club. Alexei ratmansky makes a ballet about love the new yorker. Agreeing with agathon that love is deeply connected to the ideas of goodness and beauty, socrates nonetheless insists the connection is more complex than agathon has suggested. The greek word sumposion means a drinking party a fact shamefully ignored by the organizers of modern symposia, and the party described in plato s symposium is one supposedly given in the year 416 bc by the.
In his dialogues, plato describes three different means of ascent by which the mind may ascend to the good in contemplation. Platos symposium translated by tom griffith the poet agathon hosted a symposium to celebrate victory in his first dramatic competition, the dionysia of 416 bc. Socratess discourse on love is the centerpiece of the dialogue and, in part, a refutation of agathons onesided speech on the topic. The symposium sparknotes philosophy guide making the reading experience fun. Study questions on plato s symposium in the symposium, plato gives us one of the most closeup and personal pictures of socrates we have. In it, she revives diotimas dialogue with socrates in platos symposium, challenging past approaches to. Socrates had a speech contest of praising eros, the goddess of love. What does diotima give as the result of communion with absolute beauty. According to apollodorus, soon after aristodemus and socrates arrive at. The symposium by plato exposes a set of dialogues and speeches of the leading philosophers of that historical period. While eros will refer to love in this paper, eros is also the name of the greek god of love. This is not a forum for general discussion of the articles subject put new text under old text.
With wit and insight, they all present their ideas about love from erixymachus scientific naturalism to aristophanes comic fantasy. Phaedrus, but did teach plato much of what he knew, as is assumed by many. Platos symposium lecture outline the good life at a great price. Session begins with a reading of socrates speech and his dialogue with diotima on the subject of love. Love and beauty in plato s symposium it is a widely held view that according to the symposium the ultimate or primary object of love is the form of beauty. In plato s symposium, seven very different men get together for a. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. In his celebrated masterpiece, symposium, plato imagines a highsociety dinnerparty in athens in 416 bc. In his celebrated masterpiece, symposium, plato imagines a highsociety dinnerparty in athens in 416 bc at which the guests including the comic poet aristophanes and, of course, plato s mentor socrates each deliver a short speech in praise of love. Aug 25, 2005 buy the symposium penguin great ideas new ed by plato isbn. However, there is a line in platos symposium in which diotima defines eros as a great daimon, adding that the whole of the daimonic is.
She describes eros, not as philanthropic or giving or helping for humans, but rather as always poor and far from being tender and beautiful, as the many believe and as being tough, squalid. For full text, click here after listening to a long discussion by others on love, socrates weighs in with the teachings of diotima of mantinea. Feminist interpretations of plato edited by nancy tuana. Jun 11, 2019 according to diotima, love is not a god at all, but is rather a spirit that mediates between people and the objects of their desire. Eros, woundedness, and creativity in platos symposium. Its about a contest at a mens banquet, involving impromptu philosophical speeches in praise of eros, the greek god of love and sexual desire. Describe in item either the history of love offered by aristophanes or socrates diotima. Symposium and second that object must be something of which he is at present in want. But this is the basic idea of whats meant by diotimas ladder. Amelie oksenberg rorty, as diotima saw socrates, arion 4. Apollodorus tells the story of a drinking party or symposium that occurs long ago. Plato s symposium and diotima s ladder of love plato s dialogue the symposium is one of the key texts of the platonic tradition. The symposium is considered a dialogue a form used by plato in more than thirty works but in fact, it is predominantly a series of essaylike speeches from differing points of view.
833 1281 1066 429 940 765 1057 1226 477 233 1388 115 301 1471 157 1308 586 512 1050 578 467 1144 706 376 380 1063 1115 292 162 1377 578 293 1466 1360 1250 603 217 1207 637 216 1176 247 945 432 1094 1062 55 510 1068 906 1225